Alcock v chief constable of south yorkshire police wikipedia. For secondary victims to succeed in a claim for psychiatric harm they must meet the following criteria. In a society where men live together, conflict of interests are bound to occur and they may from time to time cause damage to. Nervous shock claims are not like ordinary personal injury claims. Tort law can agreement be found with lord oliver about the. Full text of tort liability for mental disturbance and. Liability for psychiatric injury, also known as nervous shock, may pose several challenges when considered as an aspect of personal injury.
The defendants liability for negligently caused nervous shock 19 neuropsychiatrists tended to classify neuroses according to whether they followed fright, shock, general shock commotion or the combined effects of these experiences. A close tie of love and affection to a primary victim 2. To claim damages in tort, a plaintiff must prove that she is suffering from what lord bridge has described as a positive psychiatric illness mcloughlin v. As said above, the traditional approach to the duty of care in nervous shock. Consequently she suffered from nervous shock and gave birth of stillborn child of eight month. These study notes are highly recommendable for all those who aspire to crack clat, dullb, ailet and other law entrance exam. Duty of care exists if injury by shock to a class of persons including the pl. This area of tort has presented many difficulties for tortuous claims since a claim does not necessarily have to involve proof of direct involvement in an incident giving rise to the injury. The case for such a course has been argued by professor. Tort law can agreement be found with lord oliver about the law relating to nervous shock. Full text of tort liability for mental disturbance and nervous shock see other formats stop early journal content on jstor, free to anyone in the world this article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by jstor. Here we are providing you updated and most relevant study notes on tort of nervous shock for law entrance exam. Nervous shock is a term used to denote a psychiatric illness or injury caused to a person by events, due to the negligence of another person. In circumstances where a person is suffering the ongoing psychological consequences of a lifechanging event, it is often difficult to assess the amount of damages that any plaintiff could be awarded.
She sued and held motorcyclist being no responsible. I think it will be very helpful for you to keep these comments. What might be the essential features of a system of personal injury law, the sole. A compensation claim for nervous shock may be likely when an individual suffers a severe mental or emotional reaction when witnessing an accident in which, for instance, a loved one is injured or killed. In english the word tort has a purely technical legal meaning a legal wrong for which the law provides a remedy. A typical claim for nervous shock falls under the head of the psychiatric condition better known as post traumatic shock syndrome. Also held that duty to take care toward plaintiff was not anticipateable in this case.
Liability for nervous shock stephen ohalloran bcl, llm commercial the following is an extract and summary of the introduction to markesinis and deakins tort law fifth edition. Choose from 44 different sets of essentials of torts statsky flashcards on quizlet. Theoretically, there seems to be no satisfactory ground for withholding redress for wrong inflicted upon a person merely because that wrong. A remedy for nervous shock or psychiatric harm who pays. Mountbatten journal oflegal studies foreseeability. In english law, a nervous shock is a psychiatric mental illness or injury inflicted upon a person by intentional or negligent actions or omissions of another. Study notes on tort for law entrance exam nervous shock. Free unfinished flashcards about tort nervous shock. The tort law of nervous shock is a very interesting as well as important topic for all law aspirants. Law of torts revision notes, book, ebook for llblaw. The purpose of this analysis is to establish to what extent agreement can be found with regard to lord olivers judgement in alcock v chief constable of south yorkshire1. Notes on the law of torts in the area of nervous shock, workplace stress and bullying. The law of torts, a treatise on the principles of obligations arising from civil wrongs in the common law.
Fleming jg, the law of torts, 8th edition 1992 p 161 introduction 1. Free tort law books download ebooks online textbooks. In these cases, the parties were generally strangers to one another, and what happened is. The video covers all important aspects of nervous shock in tort law in a precise form. It is known as any recognizable psychiatric illness caused by the breach of duty by the defendant. Review article liability in negligence for nervous shock david w. Other activities to help include hangman, crossword, word scramble, games, matching, quizes, and tests. Would the secondary victim need to be an eyewitness to the accident. Nervous shock is the onset of a psychiatric illness caused by witnessing the negligent action, or the results thereof, of another. Alcock v chief constable of south yorkshire police 1991 ukhl 5, 1992 1 ac 310 is a leading english tort law case on liability for nervous shock psychiatric injury.
View notes law of torts nervous shock from law 1507 at university of adelaide. Start studying tort tute 4 duty of care nervous shock. Case authorities provided no consistent rules as to whether negligently caused nervous shock. Obrian 1983 ac 410, but what is commonly known amongst lawyers as nervous shock. Intentional torts, torts of negligence, and torts of strict liability. It is a term used to denote psychiatric injury or illness, inflicted upon a person by intentional or negligent actions or omissions of another. Skip to main content we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. As first published in precedent journal, issue 8, januaryfebruary 2017. For a claim of nervous shock the illness must be recognised as a psychiatric disorder. High court decides on nervous shock claim arising out of. Parry began an article on nervous shock in the following fashion. Tort is a civil wrong arising from an act or failure to act, independently of any contract, for which an action for personal injury or property damages may be brought definition of tort according to salmond. Tort is a civil wrong for which the remedy is a common law action for unliquidated damages, and which is not exclusively the breach of contract or the breach.
The case centred upon the liability of the police for the nervous shock suffered in consequence of the events of the hillsborough disaster. The types of psychiatric illnesses that are likely to form the basis of claims include. Introduction a primary victim is a victim who is directly involved in an accident and suffers injuries as a. Hi fellow law students, i am sharing pdf notes, book and ebook for the subject law of torts for llb and ba. This area of tort has presented many difficulties for tortuous claims since a claim does not necessarily have to involve proof of direct involvement in. The fact that the early cases of nervous shock, often involving miscarriage brought on by shock, are now seen as the foundation line of cases dealing with pure psychiatric harm, is signi. Tort negligence nervous shock foresight of injury volume 11 issue 3 m.
Nurhidana wahida bt khamsani 1629764 nurfauwaz hanani bt mohamad yusri 1620064 ameera daneez bt mohd shukari 1628712. It is not ordinary grief sorrow or anxiety which occurs in normal incidents in life. I term paper lb 103 law of torts the law of torts is primarily concerned with redressal of wrongful civil actions by awarding compensation. The first rule of nervous shock is, i am afraid, that you are going to struggle to succeed. Meaning, definition and nature the word tort is derived from latin term tortus which means twisted or crooked or wrong. Whether the plaintiffs mental condition amounts to such an illness is a matter for the. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The tort of negligence is based on existence of duty of care by the defendant to the plaintiffclaimant, breach. Tortnegligencenervous shockforesight of injury the. Often it is a psychiatric disorder triggered by witnessing an accident, for example an injury caused to ones parents or spouse.
That reaction may be so severe to as to cause a recognisable psychiatric condition see above. Nottingham law journal vol 23 2014 contents v editorial helen onions articles 1 proximity, psychiatric injury and the primarysecondary tortfeasor dichotomy. Nottingham law journal nottingham trent university. Mv study notes tort topic 4 nervous shock ready reckoner of cases. The attached pdf ebook of law of torts contains lecture quick revision notes that will help you understand the concepts. Learn essentials of torts statsky with free interactive flashcards. For the purposes of succeeding in a suit it must be diagnosed as more than grief or sorrow i. Free flashcards to help memorize facts about tort nervous shock ireland. High court decides on nervous shock claim arising out of motor vehicle accident. The nature op tort in general, principles of liability, persons affected by torts, general exceptions, of remedies for torts, personal wrongs, defamation, wrongs or fraud and malice, wrongs to possession and property, nuisance, negligence, duties of.
253 798 823 167 878 83 243 293 1207 493 1297 1290 931 183 932 1125 907 549 1608 291 1476 1051 289 1177 1436 494 621 1257 790 725 1134 475